I got a great question from Vitor about his hardware, the message is:
“Hello,
I had ankle surgery about a year ago following a motorcycle accident, and got a metal plate and some screws (don’t know how many exactly). I used to run before the accident and surgery, but I only ran twice recently and stopped because I was afraid I might be doing something that might damage the bone because of screws and plate being there, although I didn’t actually feel any pain while running. I’ve just imagined the screws damaging the bones with the running impact and stopped running. In a month I will have surgery to remove these metal plate and screws. Do you think I should wait until after the plate removal surgery to run?
Thank you very much!”
I responded:
Vitor, this is a really great question. When you have open reduction internal fixation (ORIF) the metal plates and screws serve as “stress risers” in the bone, which means that the bone is having to attenuate more force around the screws than they otherwise would have to if the screws were not there. Ultimately, these stress risers lead to local fractures. Additionally, the plates prevent the bones from flexing, bending and twisting. These are natural actions of the skeleton during the gait cycle especially during running activities which increases the impact loading over walking quite dramatically. The consequence of this is that other stress risers will also develop as the bone responds to the new stresses in new locations, and the result, you guessed it, fractures.
So the long and short of it is this, get the hardware removed, and then allow at least 6 if not 12 weeks to pass before you run again in order the bone to fill the screw holes. ORIF is unfriendly to runners!
Hope this helps,
Neil


Hi,
I broke my ankle and had a plate and screws put in. I was a runner before off and on before I broke my ankle so, I was surprised when my surgeon told me I could still run. I started running and building up mileage slowing about six months after recovery but, started having problems. First, plantar faciitis so, I got cortizone shots. Second, my feet started aching so, I got inserts. My knee and back sometimes hurt after I run. I feel out of alignment. I asked my primary doctor about ORIF and she agreed.I am curious about other runners results after removing plates and screws.Have any testimonials? I am thinking about removal.
Comment by Claudine — August 12, 2010 @ 9:27 am
I suggest that you push to get the hardware removed. The fact is that the bones are flexible and the hardware rigid by comparison. I know surgeons often resist the removal surgery because a. its more surgery and b. they don’t want to fracture the bone during the removal of the hardware. Especially in the Tibia where the blood supply is so sparse. Nevertheless, if you run a lot, you risk fracturing above or below the hardware in any event. So if you can talk them into removing the hardware, and you take enough time to build you mileage on a gradient, I think you will be best off.
Comment by Neil Chasan, PT, MMT — September 1, 2010 @ 9:11 am